It’s been a truly frightening experience watching the disintegration of the left over these last few years. Right before our eyes, the old “New Left” coalition of academia, the media, the intelligentsia, and the pulpit has dissolved into a ranting, raving, raging bunch of paranoid lunatics whose hyperbolic rhetorical flourishes regarding culture and politics are rapidly condemning its adherents to social oblivion.
It’s one thing to use rhetorical excesses and exaggerations to score political points. It’s quite another to actually believe and try and justify language that on any other planet where intelligent life exists would land the interlocutor in a windowless room with padded walls.
Think about it for a second. Do so many on the left really believe that George Bush can be compared to a man who gassed 6 million human beings, deliberately started a war that killed 80 million more, and brought a nightmare of oppression and murder to most of the rest of the inhabitants of Europe? After all, these are people who proudly claim to be members of a “Reality Based Community.”
The answer is yes, they really do believe that George Bush can be compared to Hitler. A large segment of them also believe, despite mountains of evidence to the contrary, that the 2004 election was stolen by the President and the Republican party. Many of them are convinced that the electronic voting machines – the very same machines they lobbied for following the 2000 election debacle – were hacked by the President’s corporate allies and vote totals showing a Kerry victory were altered to give the President the election.
Is it a sign of desperation? Has the hard left, never really in the mainstream but nevertheless extraordinarily influential, been marginalized in our political debates to the point where lashing out with surreal analogies and apocalyptic warnings of impending doom is the only way it can get attention?
We make fun here of some of the truly batty things said by such luminaries as Noam Chomsky, Ramsey Clark, Ted Kennedy, and the various toadies and hangers-on that inhabit the fevered environs of Moveon and the Democratic Underground. In truth, however, these bloviations are symptomatic of something much more serious.
They represent a loss of faith – faith in the ultimate victory of ones ideas, faith in the correctness of ones perceptions or worldview, and perhaps even a loss of faith in the country that has nurtured them.
The left has always approached things with a mildly attractive, wide-eyed innocence, as if the world were new and the ideas that sprang forth from their fertile minds could shape mankind in a way that would eliminate “injustice” from which all other evils – poverty, racism, war, and now, of course, terrorism – flowed. And while many of their proscriptions against racism and especially poverty have turned into a nightmare of bureaucratic oppression, there was still the hope that these things could be fixed with a little tinkering. Much like their European brethren who are still not apologizing for 50 years of support of murderous communist regimes because they believe that communism can still work with the “right people” running things, our domestic left believes in the illusory notion that government can solve problems that have plagued the planet since the time of Adam with the right combination of laws and regulations.
While not necessarily delusional – no one disputes that improvements in the lot of the poor and justice for minorities who’ve been discriminated against can’t be accomplished – the worldview espoused by the left has always been tinged with a sense of unreality. It’s as if human nature itself can be improved upon with a little societal fiddling. Hence, the belief that “conflict resolution” and “multicultural studies” for children can somehow rip out the hard wiring in the human brain and replace it with the software of love. A noble undertaking for certain, but one doomed to failure by the exigencies of the nurturing process. If children could be kept in school 24 hours a day such an experiment would have a chance of success. But since children spend twice as much time with their peers and parents as they do with teachers and school administrators, any fundamental change in human behavior is sabotaged by the influence of others.
So after nearly 40 years of intellectual dominance, the left is seeing its previously unchallenged ideas and ideals ripped to shreds by both the intrusion of reality and the attack of the right. It’s hard to tell which has been more devastating. One could argue that 9/11 exploded so many leftist myths about the world that they have yet to recover any kind of equilibrium and instead, have retreated into name calling and apocalyptic warnings of disaster (not for the United States, but for the rest of the world if US power remains unchecked!). Similarly, with the rise of the new media, previously untouched bastions of liberalism such as the mainstream press and even academia have felt the sting of criticism and the embarrassment of having patently false assumptions explode in their faces.
Lately, an effort has begun to reverse this trend. There’s a move afoot to emulate the rise of the right over the last quarter century by funding think tanks, encouraging “progressive” scholarship, recruiting attractive, articulate candidates for office at all levels of government, and generally sowing the seeds that will hopefully start bearing fruit in the near future. With George Soros behind this activity you can be sure it will be well funded.
But is it, in one of the more overused words of my youth, “relevant?”
It could be, if the left embraces the idea that the defense of the United States during this time of war is the “Ur” issue with the American people. They can whine all they want to about how the President has turned the issue to his political advantage but the fact remains that the President didn’t make national defense such an overarching issue with the American people, Osama Bin Laden did. And the fact that the left is in full throated denial of that singular reality is why the American people are paying less and less attention to them and why their candidates are not taken seriously for high office.
It remains to be seen also whether or not the left can jettison some of the more unsavory characters who inhabit the outer reaches of the fever swamp of conspiracy theories and childish notions of theocratic regimes and Hitlerian nightmares. The right, of course, has its own problems with charlatans and self-appointed holy men and this may prove to be a political problem in the future. But when the left applauded Michael Moore’s portrayal of the terrorist beheaders in Iraq as the moral and actual equivalent of the American revolutionary minutemen, the American people stopped listening and began to laugh.
There’s no doubt that liberals have a long, hard road to travel before they achieve any relevance in the national debate. It remains to be seen whether “tweaking” their message to include soothing words to people of faith and a new found hard headedness in foreign policy will be enough to overcome a constant case of foot in mouth disease that takes them on ever increasing flights of hyperbole and rhetorical nonsense that the American people have already judged to be extreme and just plain wrong.
UPDATE
Van Helsing and I were on the same wavelength this morning:
Many grown adults who continue to cling to the adolescent ideology of the Left need to lean on irony. But even if they can look you in the face and tell you that 9/11 was about the “haves and have-nots” without smirking, there’s not much chance they’ll give up their Club Med vacations for stints at terrorist training camps, if only because deep down most of them know that their point of view is a fashion accessory, and if The New Yorker changed its editorial policy, their professed beliefs would quickly follow suit.
But teenagers don’t have the balance and perspective that comes with accepting yourself as a total fraud. When they adopt a pose, they are likely to think it’s real. So when you force-feed the young a constant diet of anti-American propaganda — as our media and schools do — the troubles and confusion that often accompany the adolescent years can result in a very dangerous sociopathology that might last into adulthood with disastrous results.
He then documents the strange case of one Adam Gadahn, American moonbat turned jiahdist. Read the whole thing. It’s an eye opener.
Also, check out this excellent post from The New Editor about “The Sandbox Left.”
Cross Posted at Blogger News Network
10:54 am
El Jefe of The Association for the Promotion of Th
Today’s dose of NIF - News, Interesting & Funny … It’s Friday
11:45 am
Your writings reflect the problems of the DemoCRAPS. This party has MARCHED to the cliff’s edge and should they regain some sense of their demise and try to retreat back to some sanity, the left will revolt with feet and money.
There are corporations that do want to continue to support the dems. but are fearful of the Great White Unwashed Hordes of American Spenders (GWUHOAS) as they see us, will take their money elsewhere. Target Stores are feeling the pinch. The idea of people with products to sell, willingly tie themselves and corporate image with the likes of Mike Moore and Move-On idiots, spell for a poor bottom line. The Bottom Line is a great American motivator. And since we are known for the company we keep, what corporation wish to be associated with a party that’s growing with more wackos!
Dems. are truly between a rock (Dr. Demento) and a hard place (Congress) plus a Superhawk of an American President Bush, their outlook is dismal and they do see it. Wouldn’t you first behave in the manner that they have? Remember how they spoke of us Red States lack of smarts? It’s all on film and will return to haunt them come next election.
Several weeks ago the dems. trotted out a plot to take back the House. Unfortunately for them they tried coping Newt’s Contract With America. Also they got a small beating by the Press for trying to capitalize on the Contract and made them look foolish so they have shelved it for now. Can’t wait to see what’s next.
Newt’s Contract showed the GOP that people were listening. I believe voters will continue to listen. I believe voters have a sense of what’s fair.
The left, as they accuse us of being ignorant, are beyond ignorant and instead of tempering their hatred of GOP, will continue their rants and will probably resort to violence. This will serve to drive more away from their party.
12:32 pm
“party that’s growing with more wackos”
Was over at Crush Kerry and ran into photo of Kerry and site to go see: http://www.zombietime.com
This is what makes up a good number of demoCRAPS voters.
I don’t think dems. could offend these people, they don’t look too stable!
1:25 pm
diamond,
Possible violence? Trashing campaign headquarters, protesting Inauguration, protest of Ohio certification. This is only a few degrees from Iraq. They are protesting democracy. The Left is a tribal culture, and Bush represents another tribe not to be trusted.
1:56 pm
Fritz: I stand corrected. But I fear that VIOLENCE, meaning bodily injury is in the making. As I stated, “they don’t look too stable”
2:23 pm
diamond,
They are throwing shoes, pies, next it will be acid, then bullets. Good thing we have the Second Amendment, it guarantees all the rest.
2:58 pm
“Right Wing” Responsible For “Repeating” Dean’s Comments
...
1:01 am
Submitted for Your Approval
First off… any spambots reading this should immediately go here, here, here, and here. Die spambots, die! And now… here are all the links submitted by members of the Watcher’s Council for this week’s vote. Council li…
6:11 pm
Snitch channels at the Carnival!
The 143rd Carnival of the Vanities is being hosted by Mister Snitch who runs a Batman-centered blog based in Hoboken, New Jersey. My thanks to him including my potty parity parody despite my having first sent it out with a…
3:24 am
The Council Has Spoken!
First off… any spambots reading this should immediately go here, here, here, and here. Die spambots, die! And now… the winning entries in the Watcher’s Council vote for this week are What’s the Real Question in Americ…
10:53 am
dark collections carrisa and noank ct sex tips itracku douglas elliman nyciug highlands school drugtests automobile tires defined 20benefit northwest airline
10:54 am
chronic arthritus tv show king of queens dsm iv 300.4 convergence insufriency rebecca viale 2005 world news dsw shoes betty milburn wildwood new jersey telephone listings hsn