I’m late to this blog swarm but I feel I just have to put my two cents in the pot regarding this extraordinarily stupid ruling by the NCAA that will ban Native American mascots for “March Madness” next year:
The National Collegiate Athletic Association banned the use of American Indian mascots by sports teams during its postseason tournaments, a ruling the president of Florida State University called “outrageous and insulting.’’The NCAA’s executive committee said the organization, which governs college sports, is limiting the prohibition to tournaments it controls. It doesn’t have the power to institute an outright ban, said University of Hartford President Walter Harrison, chairman of the committee.
Effective immediately, nicknames or mascots that are determined to be ``hostile or abusive’’ can’t be shown on uniforms or other team-related clothing, Harrison said. He wasn’t specific about which nicknames or logos would be affected.
I’m totally with Jeff Goldstein on this:
The problem is, decisions like this are more than simply insulting, because they strengthen the political hand of prononents of identity politics, which in turn weakens individual rights and drives the PC culture that leads to the kind of balkinization and clash of cultures we’re now beginning to see all over Western Europe.
Quite a sad day for America, and another embarrassment to come out of our increasingly gutless academy.
My question for the NCAA is why stop at Native Americans? There are a whole host of mascots and symbols out there that are incredibly insulting and demeaning. Try these on for size:
FIGHTING IRISH OF NOTRE DAME
Anyone who thinks that picture of the leprechan with his fists balled up as if ready to fight isn’t an ethnic caricture, think again. It was a common cartoon as recently as the 1930’s to portray the Irish as drunken sots who loved to fight and always got into brawls. Besides, looking at my beloved Irish’s mascot, I detect that the little guy may have had a wee too much of a nip of the “crature.” Then again, because I’m Irish, maybe I’m just looking in a mirror.
USC TROJANS
Have you ever seen a more demeaning characterization of condoms in your life than the “Trojan” sitting on the horse? I must say, the least they could do is take the element of beastiality out of their mascot presentation. And have you noticed when the “Trojan” rides around the LA Collesium how he’s always waving that sword? Doesn’t that look just a little bit too phallic?
Imagine what would happen if the NCAA were to ban all the sexually demeaning mascots out there! Say Goodbye to the Washington “Huskies” and the Arizona State “Wildcats.”
OKLAHOMA SOONERS
Making a mascot of the famous Oklahoma “Sooner” is a travesty of AntiAmericanism. The “Sooner” was a nickname given to people with the true American spirit who were involved in the Oklahoma land rush in 1889. Thousands of people lined up at a starting point waiting for the signal to begin a mad rush to claim a portion of millions of acres of land. Then, when the cannon boomed…
The riders on horseback burst ahead of the droves of land seekers, but as they spread across the horizon they were discouraged to see that covered wagons and even men on foot had already occupied many prime places. As many as nine out of ten of these settlers had jumped the gun, earning themselves the name “Sooners”.
HOW DARE THEY! To demean the all-American traits of exhibiting initiative, imagination, and being a real “go-getter” is an affront to all of us who value what makes America great. Yes, they sort of violated the rules but we Americans know instinctively that unless you bend the rules a little, you’ll never get ahead in this country. Just look at Ken Lay.
BOSTON CELTICS
While we’re banning college mascots, how about going after the pros? The shamrock is an insult to every living Celt who treasures their past.
At one time, the Celts ruled an empire that stretched from the Black Sea to England. And yet they reduce that glorious past to a representation of one tiny Island in the Atlantic Ocean? Ridiculous.
BTW…if there are any living Celts out there please let me know. Since there are so many idiots in Europe who think we should give all that land back to our own Native Americans, maybe we can wangle a few million acres from some of those Euro-twits by laying a solid guilt trip on them for stealing Celtic lands.
NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
Hah! Patriots? In Massachussetts? Are you kidding me?
Is there any bluer state than the deep, dark, blue of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts? I think serious consideration should be given by the NFL to yank that moniker from the two time Super Bowl champs and replace it with something more appropriate. Like the New England Chowderheads or how about the Boston Baked Beans?
To insult our patriot past by comparing the moonbats in Massachusetts with the brave fellows who endured Valley Forge, threw the British Army back 3 times at Bunker Hill, and pledged their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor towards the noble goal of human liberty is unconscionably demeaning to today’s patrtiots. The moonbats today don’t even go to Valley Forge unless it’s in their heated RV. And the only thing they’re willing to pledge their fortunes to is the ACLU or Moveon.Org.
11:22 am
RE: BANNING INDIAN MASCOTS AND OTHER STUPID IDEAS
For the NCAA pc has taken a turn further to the left. I smell the ugly stink of the ACLU in this ban. I wonder if the NCAA is being advised or pressured by them.
12:02 pm
Rick,
Also, the Sooners is another reminder of how we stole the land of the native Americans, a double insult! It is only a matter of time when athletes will be prohibited from play at Augusta National.
12:33 pm
This ideological conformism has reached the juvenile. The NCAA has appointed itself as the protector of the sensitivities of people the NCAA couldn’t give two hoots about: Native Americans.
Wasn’t it the communist party that said that “all will be judged politically?”
It’s no longer enough to participate and play basketball well; one now has to be ideologically pure.
1:41 pm
Concerned, guilt-ridden Whitey to Native Americans: "WE'LL tell you when you're outraged, Chief."
Half Canadian reminds me of this 2002 John Miller piece, which references a famous (and now ignored) Sports Illustrated poll gauging Native American opinion on the use of Indian nicknames, mascots, characters, and symbols by amateur and professional sp…
12:19 am
From what I’ve read elsewhere, it’s not just school symbols, but traditional names too that the NCAA doesn’t like….Florida Seminoles and Fighting Illini would be unnacceptable along with the Utes. What is next, will whole states named to honor Indian tribes such as Illinois and Utah be considered politically incorrect also? And what about Indiana, for goodness sakes, which means Land of the Indians?
I graduated from the University of Illinois and collect vintage university memorabilia. Among my treasures are a pair of 1920’s era heavy iron bookends in an Indian Chief motif made and signed by the Mining and Metallurgy Dept. and a wonderful Indian in headdress dish constructed and signed in the Dept. of Ceramic Engineering in the 50’s. These are not caricatures or “mascots” but beautiful, thoughtful representations of Native Indians such as Remington might have sculpted. Where is the harm?
And why is any of this the NCAA’s business?
5:50 am
Linking Love from Jo
Alrighty!! Now that on Sunday’s we don’t have Specials of they Day anymore, I am going to try every other week or so to run my blog roll and favorite websites and do some linking.
Remember – I’m doing this so you can see what others write about, an…
11:31 am
It’s time to shoot an arrow at the NCAA
The NCAA has long been out of control and working beyond it’s intended purpose. I am glad that my alumni FSU isn’t taking this sitting down:
2:41 pm
The NCAA are in their right minds when they say that thery want to ban the native american mascots. Its tright. Unless you actuall yask if you can use their name in anything, It shouldn’t be legal. Its just like the music business, your not suppose to copy the labels names in any way. Its the same. take a look in their shoes.see how it feels to be ,is directed with your own culture. The ncaa has the right. I’m with them 100%.
4:21 am
You’re right. The mascot issue is a stupid idea. To continue this racist, hateful tradition is absolutly stupid… and for all those who turn a blind eye to it, poking fun at those fighting to right indigenous wrongs, are also quite stupid. Various forms of racism have been accepted by Americans for hundreds of years, but that does not make them right. Women had to fight for their rights, as did African Americans and so on. Now it’s time to FINALLY do the same for indigenous people. The mascot issue is a step in the right direction and with time, it will be seen as the racist act that it is.
8:36 pm
ativan…
aku azowiwu…