Right Wing Nut House



Filed under: Blogging, Ethics — Rick Moran @ 4:41 pm

Today Terri Schiavo lies at the brink of execution by order of the court, she reacts to stimuli, interacts with her family, feels pain, says things like momma and help me, and yet - according to Judge George Greer and Michael Schiavo, she’s a worthless human being worthy of death by starvation and dehydration. (Courtesy of Blogs for Terri; 2/23/05)

The rap on the bloggers so far after Jordan’s resignation is that we conducted a witch hunt, and Jordan was nothing more than a victim. The dreaded term “McCarthyism” has been thrown at us as well. However, a witch hunt demands innocence of its victim, and Jordan was anything but. (Courtesy Captains Quarters; 2/15/05)

Two stories. Two important stories. Two Blogswarms. What’s the difference?

The Eason Jordan story was driven to the fore of mainstream media coverage as the direct result of the excellent work and tireless efforts of many of the larger blogs.

The Terri Schiavo tragedy has played itself out largely on the fringes of the blogosphere. The work by bloggers has been just as excellent and just as tireless as those who brought Eason Jordan to account. But the probability is that Terri Schiavo will die. And a legitimate question can be raised asking about the indifference of most of the larger blogs to what those of us farther down the food chain are talking about and whether or not their active participation in the blogswarm could have made a difference. (UPDATE: Terri’s case has been continued until 3/18).

This disconnect spells nothing but trouble for this new media. When something as vitally important as the euthanizing of a relatively healthy but brain damaged woman gets lost in the daily dish of gossip, news, and commentary found on the larger sites, one has to ask some penetrating questions about the nature of this new media and what will drive it forward.

Now, we’re not naive here. The sphere is, after all, not a democracy. People can post on whatever topic moves them. In fact in many ways, a blogger is rewarded for blogging on things that no one else is commenting on. By the same token, however, when more than 200 blogs are involved in the fight to save Terri and nary a word is heard from people that could do the most good on this issue, something is terribly amiss.

A check of some ecosystem stats may be revealing. Blogs for Terri is ranked #123 with more than 1200 daily visitors. Technorati reveals nearly 800 individual posts mentioning Blogs for Terri (more than 5400 posts on Terri Schiavo with an unknown number of those in favor of her euthanization).

Compare those stats with ones for Eason Jordan’s story. The Ecosysetm shows the Jordan story tapering off. In its heyday, however, the Easongate site received more than 8500 hits a day, which would have put it into the top 50 sites on the TLB. However, a Technorati search turns up something interesting. Taking into account the difference in time frames for the two stories (each having lasted approximately three weeks), the number of posts on the subject are almost identical.. “Terri” stories were more than 5400 while “Jordan” stories number 5600 to date.

I guess the question that needs to be asked is why was Eason Jordan given the boot while the end of Terri’s life could be merely hours away? Jim Geraghty of TKS links to a post by Doublethink about the way the right side of the blogsophere works:

Do people on the right “vote” a blog post into popularity? No. Are research tasks assigned, or project volunteers sought? No. Glenn Reynolds provides a link to a blog, an Instalanche results, and whatever message was there is widely dispersed. Of course, there are plenty of other large blogs directing traffic, so readers and ideas certainly move independently of Glenn, but he is a major hub.

Now it’s not my intent to pick on Glenn Reynolds or any other blog by name here. And I think, while generally accurate, the quote above is an oversimplification. There are other noteworthy blogs who can flog a story and have proven that in the past. The point is that once you get above a certain level in the ecosysetm, a deadening insularity is evident in what the individual sites post about. Each has their own favorites for certain issues (is there anybody but Chrenkoff who blogs the good news from Iraq better?) and each has an interesting perspective, otherwise we wouldn’t read them now, would we?

So a better question should be asked of ourselves. Why should they care that 200 bloggers are desperately trying to save a woman’s life? Here are some answers from people who have been posting on this issue for weeks. Beth from My Vast Right Wing Consirpacy:

Yesterday I fumed all day about how there are dozens of us small to mid-size-bloggers and ONE biggie (name withheld. ed.) all staying on message with the Terri Schiavo blogburst, with little to no help from those who direct the fuckin’ traffic. While the biggies are busy patting themselves on the back for their success in taking down Eason Jordan (they weren’t the ONLY voices, BTW) and fighting with the moonbats over stupid shit like Jeff Gannon, of all things, we smaller bloggers are actually trying to effect POSITIVE change-trying to save a life, ferchrissake.

Beth’s frustration is showing through, but can you blame her? She and dozens like her have worn their fingers to the bone and feel like their efforts are not only going for naught, but that their voices are getting lost in the gigantic cave that is the blogosphere. With no amplification from larger blogs, the voices trying to save Terri are but a distant murmur, a barely discernible echo in the blogosphere universe.

Crystal of Crystal Clear has brought her perspective as a licensed famiy counselor to this issue in an email I solicited from her:

There are similar issues in blogging about Terri with regards to the facts, truth, and accountability that are similar to Easongate and Rathergate. The main difference I see is that they aren’t bringing down one big wig such as Eason or Rather. Additionally, there is a strong sense in the MSM and the Schindler’s have encouraged this (not right or wrong) of this being a right to die and right to live issue. Although I think that is indeed part of it, I think some people…myself included to a point until last week did not want to be associated with what are perceived in the MSM as right wing religious fanatics.

That’s a possible explanation. Most of the larger blogs do not post much on social issues. But is Terri’s life or death a social issue? Or something more? Here’s Cao of Cao’s Blog:

“…it’s a travesty that the larger bloggers haven’t taken the media to task the way they have in other cases such as the Rathergate affair, Eason Jordan, even the fake indian with his anti-American statements, John Kerry, and many others. There is enough information out there to show beyond a shadow of a doubt that Michael Schiavo is not who the media represents; and to me this an important case–a terribly important case–in terms of the separation of powers e.g., the Judiciary usurping legislative action (which isn’t supposed to happen), an individual’s right to legal counsel-which in Florida is supposed to be guaranteed, particularly if you’re handicapped (which Greer denied her), socialist euthanasia as happened in the ’30’s under Nazi Germany, and even the media bias in favor of Michael Schiavo’s lawyer who is parading his “Right To Die” book around on the money that was supposed to have been used for Terri’s rehabiliation…”

Cao raises some very serious issues. These are issues that have been written about since this story began but which have been ignored by those blogs who would normally look on these same issues with great interest; judicial activism, trial lawyer misdeeds, slanted coverage by the MSM.

What it comes down to is I don’t know why this issue has not cracked the digital ceiling that separates the larger blogs from the rest of us. From my own perspective, it’s very disappointing and a little bewildering that people I admire and who I’ve learned so much from would fail to particpate in this very worthy and worthwhile effort.

My fear is, this is only going to get worse. As late as the November election, the MSM either totally ignored blogs or didn’t even know what they were. Now many of the larger bloggers are finally getting some of the recognition they so richly deserve on both TV and in print. What does this bode for the blogosphere? Will the MSM exposure work to drive more traffic their way while insulating them even further from the rest of us?

For all the talk about the new media being open and self correcting, are we in danger of creating MSB’S? (mainstream blogs). A heirarchal structure would be natural given the ruthless form of democracy practiced on the internet . In such a large universe, the cream can’t help but rise to the top. But, not everybody can be made into Ben and Jerry’s Ice Cream. Some of us will remain “off-brands” for the forseeable future.

The sphere is changing rapidly. More blogs and more readers will mean upward and downward movement in the blog food chain. What will it take to stay on top? Hopefully, the ability to lead the pack on important issues facing the country. But just as importantly, the ability to recognize ideas and issues that bubble up from time to time from the bottom. Perhpas that takes as much courage and determination as bringing down an important newsman. It will certainly mean a leap beyond one’s own insular world at the top of the TLB Ecosystem.


  1. *clap* *clap* *clap* BRAVO! Well said! And obviously not written in the heat of passionate fury as my two posts about this idea were… ;)
    I’ll add one point–they do actually write about social issues to an extent; i.e. Michelle Malkin’s writings about Kid Rock’s supposed invitation to perform at the Bush twins’ inauguration party, about the oversexualization of the culture, etc. Hugh Hewitt writes about social issues as well–or at least he used to. Those are just a couple of examples off the top of my head, without even looking for more–and it further begs the question, why not this social issue?
    I’m linking this post at my site to spread the word (for what it’s worth, with my non-mainstream traffic).

    Mainstream blogs, by the way, is exactly what I’ve thought for quite some time. In the ice cream analogy, they’d be the Breyer’s or Edy’s that you can get anywhere. WE are the Ben & Jerry’s, or more as I prefer, the Godiva ice cream. High quality, selected by a few, and not known to everyone. I don’t mind that, either, as a smaller scale keeps one closer to the readers who make blogging enjoyable.

    Comment by Beth — 2/23/2005 @ 5:07 pm

  2. More thoughts on the Blogs For Terri effort
    …from Superhawk at Right Wing Nut House:

    The Eason Jordan story was driven to the fore of mainstream media coverage as the direct result of the excellent work and tireless efforts of many of the larger blogs.

    The Terri Schiavo tragedy has playe…

    Trackback by MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy — 2/23/2005 @ 5:30 pm

  3. It appalls me at the lack of concern for life in this country. Why are we so apathetic towards those who are weaker and unable to speak for themselves? Life is the ultimate right and yet we will blather on incessantly about a politician or newsperson that has stepped over a line, yet don’t seem remotely concerned about those issues that truly are a matter of life and death. Great post and you are very correct.

    Comment by kimberly — 2/23/2005 @ 6:20 pm

  4. This is not about rightwing religious fanatics, and I’m am finding more and more bias that covers what the real issues are. It is very troubling. And thanks for publishing my comment; this is not only about Terri’s life, this is politicking over an innocent woman’s life, this is about judicial power, and promoting a right to die book. Disgusting.

    Comment by Cao — 2/23/2005 @ 6:46 pm

  5. I linked and tracked back but nothing happened. Hmmmm.

    Comment by Cao — 2/23/2005 @ 7:39 pm

  6. Yup, the trackback URL for this post is broken.

    Comment by Brian B — 2/25/2005 @ 7:56 pm

  7. 128th Carnival Of The Vanities
    Thanks to the good people at Silfray Hraka for letting me host. Thanks to those who submitted a veritable cornucopia of posts of every size and kind imaginable. Without further ado, I give you the 128th Carnival of the Vanities!…

    Trackback by Belief Seeking Understanding — 3/2/2005 @ 3:58 pm

  8. There is a central point to the Terri Schiavo situation that has not been articulated well.

    In a sentence: “Our government may not be allowed to murder us.”

    It really is as simple as that.

    Yes, the big blogs have been irresponsible, but only to the degree that they have not invested time to think of what is going on before our eyes. They have become what they despise — unthinking and reflexive. This is not a fault with them as individuals; rather it is a demonstration of the systemic aspect of our entertainment culture.

    It is always easier to ridicule – there is little risk in that venture. However, the Terri Schiavo situation is fundamentally different. It demands risk. To address the issue productively, the blogger must risk doing something that they have not done before. They must request action and stake their credibility on the propriety of their cause.

    This is life in a microcosm.

    Comment by Paul Deignan — 3/2/2005 @ 8:41 pm

  9. Blogging In Spidey’s Shoes
    I don’t really care about what happened to Eason Jordan. It’s good that bloggers were able to do something about a situation that mainstream media wouldn’t touch, but it wasn’t something I was going to blog about myself. Rathergate? Yeah,

    Trackback by Heart of Canada — 3/3/2005 @ 4:28 am

  10. Where the hell are the big bloggers for Terri Schiavo?

    Superhawk raises some very important questions over at Rightwingnuthouse. The big one being:
    Where the hell are the big bloggers???
    Well here’s Michelle Malkin’s little blurb today, but…as Superhawk said in comments here:
    This is …

    Trackback by Cao's Blog — 5/10/2006 @ 12:44 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by WordPress